The best conservative places to live in America

Stacker analyzed data from Niche to rank the 50 best conservative places to live in the U.S. Niche sources data from several public data sources.  

Posted

A red farmhouse, wood house and barn in the hills surrounded by Fall trees.

Sean Pavone // Shutterstock

For conservative Americans, the ideal home setting is a large house outside the city where relaxation and family time rule—and where the community shares similar values, particularly when it comes to religion.

The aforementioned preferences come from a Pew Research Center study published in 2014 on political polarization. The research shows that members of different political groups value different things in their daily lives—starting with where they live. Four in 10 consistent conservatives in the study said they preferred rural areas to more metropolitan ones, while about three in 10 prefer small towns. Additionally, more than half of consistently conservative people wanted to have neighbors whose political views aligned with theirs.

With this in mind, Stacker analyzed data from Niche to rank the 50 best conservative places to live in the U.S. Niche sources data from several public data sources, including the Department of Education, Census Bureau, and FBI. This particular data set was acquired by filtering for very conservative politics on the 2022 Best Places to Live in America list.

The top 10 on our list scored well on public schools (Niche average of A+) and were good for families (Niche average of A+)—but they scored lower in diversity (Niche average of B), cost of living (Niche average of B), and weather (Niche average of C+). The Niche grade for weather is clearly tied to many locations being in the Midwest, where summers are humid and winters are cold.

All but two of the top 10 best conservative places to live in the U.S. are in the Midwest. Nearly all of the locations listed in the top 10 are suburbs of larger cities; many of these locations near larger cities (Nashville, Indianapolis, Cincinnati, and Milwaukee, namely) have higher median home values. The locations topping the list share certain characteristics, from lively restaurants and bars, to great schools, to myriad coffee shops and parks.

Keep reading to learn more about the top 50 conservative places to live in the U.S.

You may also like: States with the lowest property taxes

#50. Pewaukee City, Wisconsin

A pier leading out into a lake with a few boats and paddleboarders.

Canva

- Population: 14,561
- Median household income: $105,768
- Median home value: $336,400
- Median rent: $1,357
- Percent of people who own a home: 83%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#49. Bridgewater, Virginia

A brick sign for a Methodist church and homes in the snow.

Creative Commons // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 6,090
- Median household income: $62,585
- Median home value: $6,090
- Median rent: $942
- Percent of people who own a home: 64%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#48. Cottleville, Missouri

A rainbow over a community college.

Mitch Harden // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 5,439
- Median household income: $124,310
- Median home value: $348,400
- Median rent: $1,305
- Percent of people who own a home: 85%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#47. Athens, West Virginia

A waterfall coming off of a big black rock in the forest.

Billy McDonald // Shutterstock

- Population: 991
- Median household income: $52,760
- Median home value: $991
- Median rent: $700
- Percent of people who own a home: 73%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#46. New Bremen, Ohio

A blue Victorian style home.

Dhelmstetter // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 2,798
- Median household income: $80,521
- Median home value: $2,798
- Median rent: $630
- Percent of people who own a home: 81%
- Area feel: Rural

You may also like: Can you guess these famous skylines?

#45. Wilmore, Kentucky

Main street and businesses in a small town.

Nyttend // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 6,339
- Median household income: $65,964
- Median home value: $164,000
- Median rent: $832
- Percent of people who own a home: 45%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#44. Signal Mountain, Tennessee

A brown high school building in front of a bright orange sunset.

Sam Poss // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 8,574
- Median household income: $109,611
- Median home value: $338,100
- Median rent: $1,841
- Percent of people who own a home: 88%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#43. Bridgeport, West Virginia

A brown two-story historic home.

JERRYE & ROY KLOTZ M.D. // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 8,675
- Median household income: $84,295
- Median home value: $8,675
- Median rent: $1,132
- Percent of people who own a home: 74%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#42. Boise Heights, Idaho

The back deck of a modern home overlooking Fall trees on a hill.

Canva

- Population: 1,479
- Median household income: $90,969
- Median home value: $621,392
- Median rent: $1,017
- Percent of people who own a home: 75%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#41. Wetherington, Ohio

An aerial view of homes and a golf course.

Nyttend // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 1,271
- Median household income: $130,521
- Median home value: $464,100
- Median rent: $1,207
- Percent of people who own a home: 82%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

You may also like: The best places to live out your West Coast retirement dreams

#40. Five Points, Ohio

Two large white water towers, an antennae and a building with two open bay doors.

Ed!(talk)(Hall of Fame) // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 1,600
- Median household income: $136,394
- Median home value: $266,900
- Median rent: null
- Percent of people who own a home: 100%
- Area feel: Rural

#39. North Sycamore, California

A pond in front of homes on a golf course.

Thomson200 // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 45
- Median household income: $160,724
- Median home value: $1,476,600
- Median rent: $1,654
- Percent of people who own a home: 92%
- Area feel: Dense suburban

#38. Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania

A red stone church and parking lot.

Jenna Hidinger // Shutterstock

- Population: 31,361
- Median household income: $108,160
- Median home value: $315,900
- Median rent: $1,318
- Percent of people who own a home: 78%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#37. Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

People walking on the boardwalk near large beach homes.

Dex Sightseeing Photography // Shutterstock

- Population: 1,588
- Median household income: $117,083
- Median home value: $1,588
- Median rent: $1,269
- Percent of people who own a home: 82%
- Area feel: Dense suburban

#36. Crestwood, Kentucky

A farm covered in snow in winter.

Vicki L. Miller // Shutterstock

- Population: 5,034
- Median household income: $98,345
- Median home value: $276,500
- Median rent: $914
- Percent of people who own a home: 78%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

You may also like: What the 50 biggest cities in America looked like 50 years ago

#35. Forest, Virginia

A restored historic brick house with columns.

Warfieldian // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 11,075
- Median household income: $76,101
- Median home value: $11,075
- Median rent: $909
- Percent of people who own a home: 75%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#34. Springboro, Ohio

A main street lined with historic homes.

Ed!(talk)(Hall of Fame) // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 18,416
- Median household income: $107,403
- Median home value: $236,000
- Median rent: $1,291
- Percent of people who own a home: 87%
- Area feel: Rural

#33. Webster Township,

People gathered in the summer at a lake park.

Dwight Burdette // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 6,778
- Median household income: $145,833
- Median home value: $6,778
- Median rent: $1,563
- Percent of people who own a home: 97%
- Area feel: Rural

#32. Nashotah, Wisconsin

A rocking chair on a porch with stone pillars.

Canva

- Population: 1,287
- Median household income: $93,750
- Median home value: $354,900
- Median rent: $1,208
- Percent of people who own a home: 95%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#31. Fleming Island, Florida

Homes amongst the forest with ponds.

Pipas Imagery // Shutterstock

- Population: 30,582
- Median household income: $101,685
- Median home value: $278,300
- Median rent: $1,464
- Percent of people who own a home: 86%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

You may also like: These are the best cities to raise a family in

#30. Landen, Ohio

Homes on a lake in winter.

Nyttend // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 7,882
- Median household income: $90,661
- Median home value: $209,600
- Median rent: $1,205
- Percent of people who own a home: 89%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#29. Weddington, North Carolina

A historic Queen Anne style yellow home.

Creative Commons // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 11,000
- Median household income: $144,718
- Median home value: $476,400
- Median rent: $1,108
- Percent of people who own a home: 96%
- Area feel: Rural

#28. Gambier, Ohio

Gardens with a red bridge over water in a park.

aceshot1 // Shutterstock

- Population: 2,339
- Median household income: $78,864
- Median home value: $2,339
- Median rent: $670
- Percent of people who own a home: 63%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#27. Seabrook, Texas

An aerial view of homes on the ocean.

Trong Nguyen // Shutterstock

- Population: 13,849
- Median household income: $89,885
- Median home value: $267,000
- Median rent: $1,294
- Percent of people who own a home: 55%
- Area feel: Dense suburban

#26. Bainbridge, Ohio

A small historic home turned into a dental museum.

Christopher L. Riley // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 7,951
- Median household income: $111,703
- Median home value: $314,000
- Median rent: $3,501
- Percent of people who own a home: 92%
- Area feel: Suburban rural mix

You may also like: Best places to live in the Midwest

#25. Medina, Minnesota

A black mailbox in a flower bed on a residential street.

Canva

- Population: 6,549
- Median household income: $156,563
- Median home value: $547,900
- Median rent: $1,355
- Percent of people who own a home: 94%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#24. South Russell, Ohio

A sign entering South Russell with American flags lining the road.

Lynne Neuman // Shutterstock

- Population: 3,761
- Median household income: $133,750
- Median home value: $353,600
- Median rent: $1,738
- Percent of people who own a home: 97%
- Area feel: Rural

#23. Meadowbrook, Alabama

A large red brick home.

Canva

- Population: 10,110
- Median household income: $120,625
- Median home value: $293,200
- Median rent: $1,188
- Percent of people who own a home: 88%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#22. Longfellow, North Dakota

Small grey home with one car garage.

Canva

- Population: 2,625
- Median household income: $133,733
- Median home value: $292,961
- Median rent: $945
- Percent of people who own a home: 99%
- Area feel: Sparse urban

#21. Seven Fields, Pennsylvania

A winding street of row homes.

Nyttend // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 2,762
- Median household income: $105,208
- Median home value: $323,700
- Median rent: $1,716
- Percent of people who own a home: 67%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

You may also like: Iconic buildings from every state

#20. Barrington Hills, Illinois

A farmhouse with a white fence in front holding a herd of horses.

Smallbones // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 4,156
- Median household income: $157,414
- Median home value: $759,800
- Median rent: $2,732
- Percent of people who own a home: 93%
- Area feel: Rural

#19. Thiensville, Wisconsin

A group of motorcycles riding down a street.

Aaron of L.A. Photography // Shutterstock

- Population: 3,149
- Median household income: $73,846
- Median home value: $254,700
- Median rent: $1,051
- Percent of people who own a home: 68%
- Area feel: Dense suburban

#18. Lookout Mountain, Georgia

A waterfall coming off of a tall mountain cliff, surrounded by Fall trees.

Sean Pavone // Shutterstock

- Population: 1,629
- Median household income: $122,222
- Median home value: $372,000
- Median rent: $1,063
- Percent of people who own a home: 87%
- Area feel: Rural

#17. Larkin Charter Township, Michigan

A small gray house with a front porch and blooming plants in front.

Canva

- Population: 5,410
- Median household income: $114,318
- Median home value: $222,700
- Median rent: $1,078
- Percent of people who own a home: 97%
- Area feel: Rural

#16. Murrysville, Pennsylvania

Homes and farms spread out on a Fall colored hillside.

Erik Drost on Flickr // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 19,692
- Median household income: $102,189
- Median home value: $260,900
- Median rent: $1,350
- Percent of people who own a home: 90%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

You may also like: 30 things to look for when deciding where to retire

#15. Palm Valley, Florida

A park bench on a lawn lined with palm trees and blooming plants.

Canva

- Population: 20,540
- Median household income: $108,580
- Median home value: $492,200
- Median rent: $1,429
- Percent of people who own a home: 77%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#14. Nocatee, Florida

A wooden entrance sign to the Nocatee Preserve.

Michael Rivera // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 16,914
- Median household income: $124,821
- Median home value: $419,400
- Median rent: $1,974
- Percent of people who own a home: 89%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#13. Fort Thomas, Kentucky

A small downtown street of historic buildings.

Bill Eichelberger // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 16,335
- Median household income: $80,549
- Median home value: $230,300
- Median rent: $892
- Percent of people who own a home: 71%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#12. McMurray, Pennsylvania

A green table and chairs under an umbrella in a terraced backyard.

Canva

- Population: 4,167
- Median household income: $142,000
- Median home value: $331,000
- Median rent: $1,113
- Percent of people who own a home: 98%
- Area feel: Rural

#11. Indian Springs Village, Alabama

A black mailbox on a road in Fall at sunset.

Stas Walenga // Shutterstock

- Population: 2,618
- Median household income: $120,313
- Median home value: $400,000
- Median rent: null
- Percent of people who own a home: 94%
- Area feel: Rural

You may also like: Best big cities to live in America

#10. Cedarburg, Wisconsin

An aerial view of a quaint town with homes on the river.

James Meyer // Shutterstock

- Population: 11,592
- Median household income: $79,868
- Median home value: $325,300
- Median rent: $887
- Percent of people who own a home: 71%
- Area feel: Dense suburban

#9. Brentwood, Tennessee

A stone mansion with a green lawn.

dansif // Shutterstock

- Population: 42,700
- Median household income: $160,174
- Median home value: $682,100
- Median rent: $2,033
- Percent of people who own a home: 90%
- Area feel: Rural

#8. Lodi Township, Michigan

Rural homes with a pond in the front.

Dwight Burdette // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 6,551
- Median household income: $123,942
- Median home value: $6,551
- Median rent: $956
- Percent of people who own a home: 98%
- Area feel: Rural

#7. Mason, Ohio

A sunflower farm.

kml100 // Shutterstock

- Population: 33,592
- Median household income: $104,462
- Median home value: $313,400
- Median rent: $1,381
- Percent of people who own a home: 79%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#6. Zionsville, Indiana

A front porch with an American flag.

INvets // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 28,035
- Median household income: $137,265
- Median home value: $406,800
- Median rent: $1,408
- Percent of people who own a home: 85%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

You may also like: Best lake towns to live in

#5. Brookfield, Wisconsin

Flags wave at a memorial park.

Aaron of L.A. Photography // Shutterstock

- Population: 38,626
- Median household income: $107,380
- Median home value: $331,500
- Median rent: $1,495
- Percent of people who own a home: 85%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#4. Kohler, Wisconsin

A walkway through sand dunes.

Tony Savino // Shutterstock

- Population: 2,016
- Median household income: $98,500
- Median home value: $2,016
- Median rent: $1,125
- Percent of people who own a home: 91%
- Area feel: Rural

#3. Elm Grove, Wisconsin

Downtown and businesses on a main road in Elm Grove.

Porterhse // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 6,156
- Median household income: $112,500
- Median home value: $395,500
- Median rent: $998
- Percent of people who own a home: 91%
- Area feel: Dense suburban

#2. Cherry Hill Estates, Kansas

Blooming flowers on a sidewalk by a white fence.

Canva

- Population: 424
- Median household income: $135,570
- Median home value: $297,330
- Median rent: null
- Percent of people who own a home: 97%
- Area feel: Sparse suburban

#1. Cave Springs, Arkansas

A small town street.

ArkansasNationalist // Wikimedia Commons

- Population: 4,859
- Median household income: $133,981
- Median home value: $305,300
- Median rent: $1,595
- Percent of people who own a home: 95%
- Area feel: Rural

You may also like: Best places to retire in America